Robotic Process Automation vs Traditional Test Automation

Robotic Process Automation (RPA) interacts with the existing IT infrastructure with the help of Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning capabilities, to automate high volume, data-intensive, repetitive tasks, with minimal human intervention. It is used across industries to automate workflow and processes by enabling bots to interact with applications at the end-user’s device. In short, it is a series of commands executed by bots under pre-defined business rules.

The wide adoption of RPA can be attributed to increased efficiency, reduced errors, and better compliance. The fastest-growing enterprise software is beginning to have major influence over SDLC as much as it is trusted to facilitate the IT professionals in achieving high-end performance from their existing computing systems. RPA gained more popularity for efficiently reducing manual efforts  in end-to-end testing structuring the custom APIs, collaborations, and business rationales to dissolve and resolve data silos.

Once an RPA software bot is trained to recognize the task and interpret the actions of specific processes in existing software applications, it can then be trained to extract raw information and deliver it to the target code from front-end to back-end without causing any changes in the existing infrastructure. Manipulating the captured data, triggering responses, initiating new actions and communicate with other systems autonomously can be taught based on the process requirement. This mechanism improves agility and reduces the paucity of a complex testing cycle which is in general chocked with custom APIs and integrations. This way, the time spent on merging and managing APIs can be used to focus on the core responsibilities of testers and developers.

In a nutshell, Test automation is a method of automating the testing procedures using a code or software tool while RPA is a practice of automating the business processes using software robots. In an ever-changing business climate, RPA is playing a fundamental role in enhancing QA and providing businesses with an opportunity to add more value to their underlying stability and scalability models with less investment.

Automates REPETITIVE TIME-CONSUMING RULES-BASED Tasks

RPA Results in:

92%

Improved Compliance

90%

Improved Accuracy

86%

Improved Productivity
Costs:

1/3rd

of an offshore employee

1/5th

of an onshore employee
RPA is expected to achieve near-universal adoption by the end of
2030
$3.11 Billion

Expected market value of RPA by 2025

Grand View Research

Is RPA similar to Traditional Test Automation?

In principle, both RPA and Test Automation can be compared with their offerings around automation. Both also reduce manual intervention and improve the quality of the outcome. However, the extent of use for both the processes vary greatly. For example, in an e-commerce business, test automation can only be applied for the website or products. But RPA can be applied to several other business processes such as data entry for product description, automating the onboarding process to make HR operations seamless.

Here are the major differentiators listed between test automation and RPA:

Test Automation Robotic Process Automation
Should be applied to a product Can be applied to products and other business processes
Has to be implemented across different environments (QA, Prod, UAT) Only needs a single production environment
Limited to a particular set of users Could be used by all individuals across the team

Though there are many Test automation tools to for functional and regression testing, RPA is particularly preferred for its simple life cycle and easy adoptability. The main drawback of Test automation tools is, they are built for a specific product or application type (such as Mobile, Desktop or Web-based). On the other hand, RPA can be applied to processes and can be customized based on the requirement, so they aren’t bounded. User Acceptance Tests has been more accurate and effective with the involvement of RPA. That could be one of the reasons RPA is considered as a new power tool for Testing.

Are they Potayto – Potahto?

No, they aren’t. RPA tools are expected to run on the business production environment to achieve business tasks. Whereas, traditional test automation tools are intended to validate whether an IT application is performing as per the given specifications. So, they are clearly aimed to solve two different problems.

Then why are they often compared?

They both are Automation tools that can be used for record and playback. They both have capability to perform (or support) each other’s tasks but their design maturity and intent are completely different.

Our VP – Engineering who was also a hands-on QA professional shared a throwback which is a perfect example to demonstrate the Process Automation capabilities of Traditional Test Automation tools. In his words:

This is from the times where we had to walk-around and find innovative fixes for the day-to-day business problems with the limited tools and platforms available. Artificial intelligence wasn’t really matured enough to rely on. Due to a technical error, we had to process $1 refunds to about 250,000 out of a million customers. It was quite a hefty job to pull out the 250,000+ accounts from the main database, validate them and perform the refunds to each. It had to be done in one go and it can’t go wrong. We didn’t have any RPA tools that are matured enough to do what’s needed. So, we have created a business case and used a popular functional and regression test automation software to validate the logic as a test case and deploy the same. Instead of using it in a testing environment, we have exercised it in a production environment.

Similarly, RPA tools can perform Test Automation tasks, if needed. After all, they are made to automate any clerical task that is repetitive, pre-defined and can be scripted.

What’s next?

The concept of applying Robotic Process Automation can be traced back to the early 2000s, exploiting the software bots to take the load off manual testers has become popular in recent times. And today, RPA software is predominantly used in organizations where they have multiple complicated systems that need to interact together fluidly. The practitioners believe that RPA can change the face of software testing since it is not reliant on any specific programming language as much as an application that is being executed on a VM can also be automated.

What we’ve learned from our seasoned experts is, ‘What tool you use is important but how efficiently you use it determines the success or failure of the attempt’. We always believe in exploring the full capability of software and experiment to accelerate their potential. Being a Technology company with a focus on Quality, Innovation is an on-going process at Qentelli. Stay tuned for more detailed documentations of our Quality Assurance processes and new-age Automation efforts.

Struggling with a business challenge? We might have an answer. Reach us: info@qentelli.com